Linkedin

Risks and opportunities of developing green and brownfield sites in the context of drainage.

September 24, 2024

In urban planning and construction, the terms greenfield and brownfield sites are often used to describe different types of land available for development. While both refer to land that can be built on, they have fundamental differences that impact drainage opportunities and risks. Here is a breakdown:

Greenfield Site

Definition: A greenfield site refers to undeveloped land, typically in a rural or semi-rural areas that has never been built on or used for industrial, commercial, or residential development.

These sites are often agricultural land, countryside or natural spaces that have not previously been developed such as farmlands, forests and open fields areas.

Drainage Opportunities:

  • Offers more flexibility in design and planning as the land is essentially a “blank slate”. This generally provides more space and opportunities for the implementation of SuDS features in coordination with a new landscape design.
  • The site is not contaminated land, and earthworks will generally not require any remediation.
  • The risk of pollutant discharge into the existing groundwater is generally low and surface water infiltration into the ground is an option when the geology presents the right conditions.
  • There are usually fewer utilities within the ground leading to reduced coordination issues.
  • In areas at risk of flooding, there is generally more opportunity to provide resilience and resistance measures to protect against flooding of the site.

Drainage Risks:

  • The proposed development will have to take into account the impact on the existing eco-habitat e.g. trees may need to be retained, and roots protected in certain places, or the road design and landscape design may need to allow for the transit of a particular species of animal.
  • There will be less established infrastructure in place (roads, drainage systems and utilities), which can make initial development costly.
  • Where no sewers are present within the vicinity of the site, the discharge of foul water into the ground or a watercourse may be the only method of foul water disposal.
  • In areas at risk of flooding, developers may have to demonstrate that sites at lower risk have been considered for the development (this is called a “Sequential Test”).

 

Planning approval:  Developing greenfield sites in the UK often faces opposition due to environmental concerns and policies aimed at protecting the countryside and preventing urban sprawl. In line with the National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF), greenfield developments must undergo thorough environmental assessments, and approval can be difficult to obtain without proper justification.

 

Brownfield Site

Definition: A brownfield site refers to previously developed land, often in urban or industrial areas. This type of land is typically being repurposed or redeveloped.

These sites were previously used for industrial, commercial, or residential uses, such as old factories, warehouses, abandoned buildings or old residential properties that are now being replaced by new developments.

Drainage Opportunities:

  • Aids with the regeneration of urban areas, reducing pressure on greenfield developments and limiting urban sprawl.
  • Typically located closer to existing infrastructure, transport links and services which can lower drainage infrastructure costs.
  • The presence of existing nearby sewers is high, providing a discharge option for foul and surface water, if required
  • At sites at risk of flooding, regeneration may present an opportunity to implement a drainage strategy in accordance with vigorous design standards, reducing existing flood risk.
  • May qualify for government grants or incentives aimed at urban regeneration and environmental cleanup.

Drainage Risks:

  • Potential contamination from previous use may require remediation which can be costly and time consuming.
  • Contamination may also limit the opportunities for surface water infiltration and discharge alternatives would need to be considered.
  • The presence of existing utilities may limit the options for the landscape proposals and the implementation of SuDS features.
  • Existing drainage will have to be re-designed for larger return periods and provide significant attenuation, sometimes taking an important part of the land.
  • Redevelopment may place additional pressure on existing infrastructure and public services in the area.
  • There is generally more chance of unforeseen constraints arriving, hindering drainage design possibilities.

 

Planning Approval: In the UK, redeveloping brownfield sites is actively encouraged by the government as part of sustainable development strategies. The NPPF prioritises brownfield regeneration to reduce the environmental impact of new developments and preserve greenfield land for future generations.

Conclusion

Both greenfield and brownfield sites offer unique opportunities for development but come with their own set of challenges with regards to drainage design. Greenfield sites often offer a more straightforward development process but raise significant environmental concerns. In contrast, brownfield sites can be more complex due to potential contamination, utilities and limited space issues but are aligned with sustainable urban regeneration goals.

Ultimately, the decision to develop on a greenfield or brownfield site depends on project objectives, environmental impact, and cost considerations.

 

Civilistix Services:

Planning Services Cambridge | Civilistix

Flood Risk Assessments (FRA’s) | Civilistix

News & Views

Latest Updates

How Topographical Surveys Inform Drainage Design

November 12, 2026

How Topographical Surveys Inform Drainage Design

Topographical surveys help identify overland flow routes and low points where water may collect. Accurate survey information supports informed drainage design, flood risk assessment and site layout decisions from the outset.

Manhole Backdrops: The Pros and Cons

November 6, 2026

Manhole Backdrops: The Pros and Cons

Manhole backdrops can offer excavation savings and design flexibility, but introduce hydraulic and maintenance challenges. Their use requires careful consideration of site constraints, adoption requirements and long-term drainage system performance.

Why Drainage Easements Matter to Site Layout and Detailed Design

October 29, 2026

Why Drainage Easements Matter to Site Layout and Detailed Design

Drainage easements can influence building positions, drainage strategies and development costs. Identifying these constraints early helps project teams coordinate site layouts, maintain sewer access and avoid unnecessary redesign or diversions.